'Graveyard' fear as sub's hull is holed

Published: 3 Apr 2008 09:20

Expert's concern as diver finds hole in hull of decommissioned nuclear submarine

A HOLE has been discovered in the hull of a radioactive nuclear submarine at Rosyth Dockyard, renewing safety fears about the decaying vessels.

It is the first incident of its kind involving the seven decommissioned subs at Rosyth since the Ministry of Defence starting laying them up afloat at the yard 25 years ago this month.

The hole, about the size of a fist, was found by a diver on the Polaris sub, HMS Revenge, during a routine inspection in February.

Leading nuclear consultant John Large predicted that the deteriorating condition of the redundant boats will lead to Rosyth becoming 'a nuclear graveyard' for the UK"s old subs.

Mr Large, who advised Russia after the Kursk submarine disaster, said 'indecision and incompetence' from the MoD and Royal Navy on the fate of the hulks would result in 'Rosyth becoming a nuclear dump by default'.

He added, 'This is a significant incident as it will force the MoD to finally make a decision on this after years of humming and hawing.'

The vessel will be taken into a dry dock in May to allow a full inspection and repairs to be carried out.

For years, arguments have raged about what should done about the 'rusting hulks' lying at Rosyth.

However, a MoD spokesman told the Press the hole had been caused by microbes and not by rust.

'This type of microbe attack is quite common on offshore industry installations,' he added.

The high-level radioactive fuel has long since been removed from the vessels. However, large radioactive reactor compartments remain in the middle of the subs.

The damage was discovered on one of six external ballast tanks, which are about half an inch thick compared to the inner hull, which is an inch and a half thick.

A spokesman for the MoD said, 'There are six external ballast tanks and 10 internal ballast tanks. There was never any danger of the boat sinking. Even if there were holes in the six external tanks that wouldn"t happen.'

John Howie, Babcock"s managing director for warships, said, 'We are confident that the problem recently identified with the laid up submarines poses no radiological risk.

'We are working closely with the MoD to plan and undertake the docking of Revenge for maintenance and preservation.'

A lengthy consultation exercise, ISOLUS, was carried out into the storage of the radioactive waste from the submarines until a permanent repository is found.

However, so far the Government has failed to come up with a decision.

Mr Large said, 'They have a very serious problem to deal with at Rosyth.


'The indecision and incompetence shown by the Ministry of Defence and Royal Navy over what to do with these boats has been absolutely staggering.

'They"ve had no strategy and just to leave them afloat to rot really beggars belief.

'You have to remember that up until 1985 the Royal Navy"s policy on what to do with these old nuclear submarines was simply to dump them at sea.

'Sadly for the people of Rosyth and Scotland, they are being left with the legacy having had no benefits since the submarine re-fitting work was moved to Devonport for political reasons.

'Basically, Scotland is being left with the rubbish and I would imagine this will bring the Royal Navy up against the Scottish Government.

'I would imagine that when they take Revenge out of the water, it will be like a car"s MoT - once they find one thing wrong they"ll find others.

'They will play down the incident but many parts of the submarines are inaccessible.

'I think they"ll decide that Revenge has come to the end of its life afloat and if it"s true for one, it"ll be true for others - Dreadnought for a start.

'These boats have been lying so long that radioactivity seeps through the bilges.

'When they store the first submarine on land that will be the start. I can see the rest going there because the MoD will not want more than one site.


'That would see Rosyth becoming Britain"s nuclear graveyard for the ones already at Rosyth, the ones at Devonport and the rest still to come out of service over the next few years.

'Even if the U.K. was to take the decision today to have a national depository for nuclear waste it would be 2035 to 2040 before it was ready.

'While the ISOLUS programme and consultations went on for years over what to do with the waste - with no decision at the end - time has been ticking and now the condition of the submarines means that the decision has been made for them. They will have to stay where they are because corrosion has started.'

George Anderson, who for many years ran the campaign group, Rosythwatch, said, 'When I went to these ISOLUS meetings, I used to come out more depressed than when I went in.

'It was obvious that none of them had any idea what to do with this nuclear waste, military or civil.

'At the end of it all, nothing become of ISOLUS and now I hear they"re talking about starting another consultation in 2009.

'All the time the submarines have just been left lying down there.

'For all I"ve slagged the MoD over the years, the real culprits are the politicians. They"ve ducked taking the hard decisions and now you don"t hear any of them wanting to talk about what we should do with the nuclear waste.'

In April 1983, Britain"s first nuclear sub, HMS Dreadnought, was towed into Rosyth at the end of her service and remains laid up there.

Controversial plans by Babcock to create the world"s first land store for radioactive submarines at Rosyth were rejected by the MoD in 2001.

However, the Scottish Government recently earmarked Rosyth as a potential nuclear waste store in its National Planning Framework, along with five other possible sites.

Jump to first paragraph.

Get more stories from our Roundup section

15 Apr 2014 17:30 • Ross Hart

Carnegie Spartans Gymnastics Club celebrate 40th anniversary

MORE than 750 gymnasts from across the UK and Ireland helped Carnegie Spartans Gymnastics celebrate its 40th anniversary recently.

Social: Comments0 comments

14 Apr 2014 16:15

Hat-trick for St Columba's fencers

ST COLUMBA'S girls fencing team scooped two golds and a bronze at the recent Scottish Fencing School Team Championships, making it three consecutive years that the girls have won the foil and sabre events and medalled in the epee event.

Social: Comments0 comments

14 Apr 2014 12:30 • Ross Hart

Canmore Primary School display spirit of sport!

ENERGETIC kids at Canmore Primary School saw their enthusiasm rewarded at a sports festival.

Social: Comments0 comments

14 Apr 2014 11:15 • Stuart Findlay

Access changes at Dunfermline's Queen Margaret Hospital

PATIENTS are being advised of changes to the entrance of the Queen Margaret Hospital's outpatients clinic from today.

Social: Comments0 comments

14 Apr 2014 10:27

Police warn Fife shopkeepers after change scam

FIFE police have warned retail and commercial staff to watch out for an ongoing scam known as 'Ringing The Changes' following an incident on Friday.

Social: Comments0 comments

14 Apr 2014 09:00 • Stuart Findlay

Dunfermline MSP to make last-ditch appeal to save Pitcorthie

DUNFERMLINE MSP Cara Hilton could make a decisive intervention in the Pitcorthie vote after being granted five minutes to outline her opposition to the plans at Tuesday’s crunch meeting.

Social: Comments1 comment

13 Apr 2014 12:30

BBC Scotland to use film of Jim (88) for Forth Road Bridge 50th anniversary

BBC Scotland are making a documentary for the Forth Road Bridge’s 50th anniversary – using an amateur filmmaker’s unique personal footage.

Social: Comments0 comments

13 Apr 2014 07:00 • Stuart Findlay

WATCH: Fife Flyer makes the cut for charity

A FIFE FLYER chopped off his trademark beard to help raise almost £4000 for a good cause.

Social: Comments0 comments

11 Apr 2014 16:09

VIDEO: New Queensferry Crossing: From 0 to 200metres in three months!

WATCH! Stunning timelapse of the new Forth crossing taking shape

Social: Comments2 comments

11 Apr 2014 10:45 • Ross Hart

Dunfermline Athletic pledge support to Jordan Moore in skin cancer battle

DUNFERMLINE chairman Bob Garmory has backed Jordan Moore to win his battle with skin cancer.

Social: Comments0 comments

11 Apr 2014 09:53

Fife school pupils work together to stay smoke-free

SECONDARY school pupils across Fife are working together to help make sure they stay smoke-free.

Social: Comments1 comment

10 Apr 2014 16:30

British Transport Police launch probe after sectarian singing on train between Kirkcaldy and Edinburgh

BRITISH Transport Police (BTP) has launched an investigation and condemned the actions of a group of football supporters who sang sectarian songs as they travelled on a train between Kirkcaldy and Edinburgh on Sunday.

Social: Comments0 comments

10 Apr 2014 16:00 • Stuart Findlay

NHS Fife reassure public over staff shortages

NHS Fife has reassured the public they have contingency plans to deal with staff shortages after revealing the number of vacant posts for key medical staff has risen.

Social: Comments1 comment

10 Apr 2014 15:20 • Ross Hart

West Fife trio Caroline Weir, Lucy Graham and Katey Turner help Scotland women's under-19s to European Championships

THREE West Fife footballers have helped Scotland women's under-19 team qualify for the European Championship finals.

Social: Comments0 comments

10 Apr 2014 10:30 • Ross Hart

NHS Fife meet cancer waiting times

FIGURES released by Information Services Division Scotland have revealed that NHS Fife are meeting national waiting time targets for cancer patients.

Social: Comments0 comments

9 Apr 2014 15:00 • Ross Hart

Best pals back in the saddle for Glasgow

WEST FIFE cycling duo Charline Joiner and Eileen Roe are on track for this summer's Commonwealth Games after overcoming injury and illness problems.

Social: Comments0 comments

9 Apr 2014 14:45

Save more than £100 on Easter family day trips in tomorrow's 80-page Dunfermline Press

YOU can save more than £100 with our great offers which include 2-for-1 entry at Alton Towers, one free child ticket at Deep Sea World in North Queensferry and kids go free at the Hampden experience in tomorrow's Dunfermline Press.


8 Apr 2014 12:30

Fife social work care users set to get pay increase

SOCIAL work care users and their personal assistants (PAs) are set to get a pay increase.

Social: Comments0 comments

8 Apr 2014 12:20 • Ross Hart

Police appeal for information over missing Falkirk man who may be in Fife

OFFICERS from Police Scotland are appealing for information about the whereabouts of a missing man from Falkirk who may be in Fife.

Social: Comments0 comments

8 Apr 2014 08:40 • Stuart Findlay

NHS Fife apologises for 'lack of urgency' after woman collapses and dies in A&E

NHS FIFE has apologised to a family after being accused of showing a “lack of urgency” and failing to identify the severity of a patient’s condition.

Social: Comments3 comments