Skip Navigation, Sitemap

Dunfermline Press

Published: Wednesday, 28th July, 2010 9:30am

Defective Crombie homes set to be flattened

Comments (6) | Print | Email

A £2.5 MILLION housing regeneration project in Crombie will get underway by the autumn, the Press can reveal.

Phase one of the renewal strategy of the 50 defective Unitroy homes - which were declared "statutorily defective" in 1987 - is expected to start as soon as September.

The homes were condemned because of the steel-framed design, with the cost of repairing each one estimated at £40,000 - or a total of £2million to replace.

Residents had been left with damp and draughty homes, with sky-high heating bills as a consequence.

A total of 20 homes will be demolished in the first phase, and the Scottish Government and Fife Council will fund the development of 18 new houses this financial year.

The project is being undertaken by the Fife Housing Association Alliance (FHAA), with Kingdom Housing Association (KHA) as lead developer and Fife Housing Association (FHA) taking over as landlords upon its completion.

Of the 50 homes, which are located in Central Road, Main Road and Farm Road, 33 are owned by FHA with the other 17 privately owned.

Decanting is already underway, and the Press understands all but two tenants have already moved, and that 12 of the 17 private properties have been bought back.

KHA development manager Scott Kirkpatrick said, "The key thing is that we've got programme approval from the Scottish Government.

"That means we are looking to go ahead with the rebuild project for phase one, this financial year, which will be before March 2011.

"FHA, who are the landlord, have been emptying the properties for phase one, so that they can take forward the demolition of the houses.

"We're hoping to be able to start that process towards the end of this calendar year in terms of demolition."

Mr Kirkpatrick said KHA planned to start the new-build development "very early in 2011".

He added, "The new houses will probably be built in two sub-phases, so that some people can move into their new houses more quickly and to allow more flexibility to make effective use of the overall development area."

Phase one will have a housing mix of two three-bedroom cottages for wheelchair users, four two-bedroom cottages, six two-bedroom houses, four three-bedroom houses and two four-bedroom houses.

The houses cost an average of £138,000 each, but Mr Kirkpatrick said, "A lot of the cost is going towards getting the ground prepared for level access from the front.

"These are relatively large houses and wheelchair access is relatively expensive as well.

"It's well above the average but it's important that FHA has an asset that has meaning on their accounts.

"It was never going to be a cheap development but we're keen not to have a compromise on the specifications."

The Press understands the overall development will take place in three phases, but Mr Kirkpatrick would only confirm that "further phases" were being considered.

He also said the Alliance hoped to build a total of 35 new homes in the coming years, but did not give a timescale.

He added, "Both the Scottish Government and Fife Council will be providing funding for this project, so we need to develop our proposals so that we have the costs confirmed at a level that we can demonstrate is good value for money."

Dunfermline West MSP Jim Tolson, who has pressed the Scottish Government for funding assurances for the regeneration, welcomed the news.

He added, "What I want to see is the first phase of the new houses completed to time and budget and that will help make sure we receive the funding required for the second and third phases in due course."

Crombie Community Council also looked forward to the development.

Chair Caroline Welch said, "This will bring an energy and vibrancy and also encourage our community spirit to bloom.

"We have a very active community council who are eagerly awaiting new families to the phase one. We will continue to work towards completion of phase two and three."

Have your say. Post a comment on this article.

  • CONCERNED
    Unregistered User
    Jul 28, 20:48
    Comment: 12693

    How new familes i thought the tennents are getting there new houses back once built .WHAT i would like to no where are these tenans just now living .IF IN other accomadation will they be staying there until new houses are built .THEY should be put in caravans like my parents did quite lot of years ago then moved back so they were not taking up houses which folk were waiting to be alocated them on councils waiting list .
    Report this comment

  • Bob the Builder
    Unregistered User
    Jul 29, 20:59
    Comment: 12724

    What I'd like to know is why you pay for a survey when you buy your house? I was always led to believe you paid your money and took your chance, and if you later discovered something untoward, then you, as the homeowner had to bear the cost.
    Report this comment

  • CONCERNED
    Unregistered User
    Jul 30, 10:15
    Comment: 12731

    Bob the builder these houses were all council so most of them would have been in since they maybe were built bought them long time ago when you could get good discounts for being council tenants .These are the ones that they will be saying are private .
    Report this comment

  • Bob the Builder
    Unregistered User
    Jul 30, 21:03
    Comment: 12748

    Concerned, the article says that 50 Unitroy homes will be demolished - 33 are owned by the FHA, which leaves 17. The article states that 17 are privately owned, of which 12 have been bought back. By implication, ALL these houses are going, whether private or tenanted.

    As I said before, irrespective of whom the previous owner was 'Caveat Emptor' applies - buyer beware. Or not, as seems to be the case here. Maybe I could use this precedent to force the builder of my house [who are still building just along the road] to buy it back at its purchase value AND refund my expenditure to sort illegal plumbing, out-of-level floors, draughty windows etc that the survey didn't pick up, that the NHBC and builder collectively deny responsibility for, but that I expect to foot the bill for since that's the way property law is supposed to work!!
    Report this comment

  • macaroni badgers
    Unregistered User
    Aug 3, 12:20
    Comment: 12820

    There are 20 houses to be demolished, they are replacing them with 18 new houses... meaning 2 families will be without homes?

    Will it be the FHA homes being demolished? What about the other 13 if it is?
    Report this comment

  • JimP
    Unregistered User
    Aug 9, 18:13
    Comment: 12906

    TheseCrombie tenants should have been able

    to choose a new landlord as they have

    been badly let down in the past by Fife Housing Association (FHA).

    FHA did nothing about the Crombie tenants complaints and ignored them.

    The Crombie tenants had to go to their MSP and MP before anything was done.

    The last choice of landlord they must want is FHA who made them suffer for years.
    Report this comment

Post a comment

Registered users log in here

If you are registered with us, you can login here. If you are not registered, do so now.
Once logged in you wont have to complete word verification each time you post.

Prefer not to register?

Usernames must be 4 - 20 characters. Registration only takes a few minutes. Registered users can also take part in competitions and other features of the site.


Enter the text as shown.

I want to...

Photosales Search

Looking for a picture from the newspaper?
Visit our photosales site and search now.

Vote

Dunfermline Press Poll

Should there be only one A&E unit in Fife?

This Poll is now closed.

Yes (3.4%)

No (96.6%)

Connect South Queensferry

News from around the area