Rats alive! Villages plagued by menace
Calls to Fife Council to deal with rats in Torryburn and High Valleyfield have "increased by 150 per cent in a year".
And Anne MacFarlane says the figures back up her claim that vermin are being attracted by food waste in brown bins - part of the new four-bin trial being introduced by the council.
She stays at The Ness in Torryburn and said, "The two areas where they've tried this pilot have experienced a rise of 150 per cent in call-outs in the past year so what are the council going to do about it?
"I do not have any problem at all with recycling but I think they should stop the food waste part of this and engage with the people experiencing a problem."
Anne stopped putting food waste into the brown bin after seeing rats in her garden, and her neighbour's garden.
The brown bins have small holes in the side to aid composting and she believes the unwelcome visitors are being attracted by the smell of the food waste.
Figures provided by Fife Council for High Valleyfield show there were two call-outs to deal with rats in 2007-08, five in 2008-09, three in 2009-10 and eight in 2010-11.
Since the start of April, there have been a further two call-outs this year.
In Torryburn, there were no call-outs to deal with rats between 2007 and 2009, there were two in 2009-10 and five in 2010-11.
The figures show there has been another call-out since April.
Miss MacFarlane said, "Thirteen visits in 2010-11 may not seem like a lot but it's 13 separate visits to deal with rats - and that's only the recorded call-outs.
"It's increased by 150 per cent in a year. I know a neighbour who has never called the council out and he says he's caught 10 rats!
"It's £35 a time for the council to come out, have a look and lay the poison down so that's why people have been putting down traps themselves."
She added, "As for those who say it's because we live by the Forth, why weren't there are any call-outs for rats in 2007-09 then?
"And High Valleyfield isn't by the river, what about the rise in call-outs there?"
Douglas Mayne, a team leader in Fife Council's environmental strategy department, said, "In percentage terms, yes, it demonstrates a significant increase but the actual numbers, given the size of the population in that area, it's not an awful lot and the figures we have suggests the argument doesn't stand up.
"We did a comparison and looked at figures covered by the four bin system and it's not come up as a major issue.
"For the whole of Glenrothes, the number of call-outs for rats in 2008-09 was 51, in 2009-10 it was seven and in 2010-11 it was six.
"In Markinch, for the same years, it was four, one and zero and for Leuchars, which was also in a pilot area, it was five, two and zero.
"To put that into perspective, for the whole of Fife there were 1323 call-outs for rats in 2008-09, 1333 in 2009-10 and 979 in 2010-11.
"The food waste attracting rats, it's not something we have come across before, and we have around 50,000 households on this system recycling food waste. The figures for the pilot areas don't seem to back it up either.
"Whether that's under-reporting, I'm not in a position to say, but there are natural variations from one area to the next and a whole range of factors."
Johnston Little, of High Valleyfield community council, said, "I've never heard about a problem with rats up here, I'm sure the folk up would be on to me if there was.
"I wouldn't think the bins would have anything to do with it as you put the food waste in a bag before it goes in the bin."
Sheila Carribine, the chair of Low Valleyfield community council, added, "I don't tend to use it as I have a compost heap but if there's food waste it could be attracting vermin.
"However, at the West Fife and Coastal Villages Forum there are representatives of all the different community councils and if had been a really serious issue I think it would have been mentioned there.
"It may be a coincidence as there are always complaints about vermin from time to time."
Have your say. Post a comment on this article.
-
Albert Tatlock
Unregistered User
Aug 6, 10:43
Report commentI know there are lots of rats around the Sinclair Gardens Rounabout area, the place is infested.
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 0
-
******
Aug 6, 13:27
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
******
Aug 6, 17:59
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
wee eck
Unregistered User
Aug 6, 20:50
Report commentthe press is just like that programme on the telly, friends, every story seems to be the same, or yon film when every day was the same,, cant mind the name of it, well you get the drift.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
Syd Carrott
Unregistered User
Aug 7, 02:23
Report commentI saw a few rats kicking about there, most of them were the two legged variety mind.
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 0
-
wee eck
Unregistered User
Aug 7, 14:10
Report commentah joe glad to see you back on your medication.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 0
-
Bin bag
Unregistered User
Aug 10, 12:05
Report commentI for one would rather know if the new brown bins are going to pose a rat problem.Thanks to Anne we may not have to face the problems Torryburn residents are.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 1
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 10, 20:11
Report commentTwo sides to every story bin bag. Fester aside, we haven't had any rat problems in the next village along during our 6 month (plus) inclusion in the trial.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 0
-
Bin bag
Unregistered User
Aug 10, 23:04
Report commentDoes Fester ever make valid comments ?. Thank you All recycled good to know rats aren't too major a problem.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 0
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 09:40
Report commentYou're welcome bin bag. If you think about it all we are doing is placing the food waste in an alternative bin. The waste food has always been generated. Before it went in the grey bin, now it's a brown one, along with the garden waste. The bin is emptied fortnightly along with the grey bin. Either way the food waste is sitting in a bin somewhere for a fortnight. The council provide biodegradable bags to place the food in before placing it in the brown bin, so it's not lying exposed, or shouldn't be if people recycle properly. I think it that it has been a huge success personally. Along with the blue and green bins this has reduced our waste that goes into the grey bin to next to nothing. So much so that I requested the small version of the grey bin, and to be honest I could put that out 4 weekly now. We are a family of 5 plus dog, by the way.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 0
-
Bin bag
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 11:07
Report commentOh the vermin is here sad get. Conversation too intelligent for him probably.
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
Bin bag
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 11:10
Report commentThank you recycled but are there not holes in the new brown bins ? That's why people think rats and other vermin may be attracted.
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 0
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 12:19
Report commentYes there are small air holes in each side. Before the trial, uncooked food could be placed in the brown bin unbagged. I now place all the waste food in the bags provided and seal them before placing in the brown bin. I can't say categorically that it eliminates all smells, just that we have haven't had any pest probems. Not even when the bins were not collected for about 5 weeks during the heavy snow last Dec/Jan.
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 0
-
Accurat
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 14:15
Report commentIf you actually cared to read(presuming you can)the full threads on this, then you would know that the worry with the new bins was the addition of ventilation holes which may allow vermin to be attracted to the food smells.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 1
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 14:47
Report commentAccurat, if you cared to read the full threads on this then you would know that the brown bins have ALWAYS had ventilation holes in the side, this is not an addition. New brown bins were not distributed for the trial, we carried on using the ones that we've had for years. If you are unaware of this you presumably have not been using yours. And if you bothered to understand the posts on this you would also know that food has been placed in the brown bin since their introduction years ago. Since the trial began biodegradable bags have been provided free of charge to place waste food in and this now includes cooked waste food. That is the difference.
So no need to worry your silly little airhead about it any longer.
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 1
-
accurat
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 15:59
Report comment -
accurat
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 16:23
Report commentMy brown bin has always been for garden waste by the way.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 16:50
Report commentDon't attack and then not expect retaliation >:(
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
accurat
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 16:54
Report commentI attacked UJ's ignorant comments not you !!.I actually agreed with all you said.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 17:09
Report commentI apologise. People don't usually bother explaining things in response to ujs comments. I couldn't make head nor tail of what he was driving at anyway. And I didn't realise that you meant it in agreement with my post. I retract my last sentence to you.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
Bin bag
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 18:29
Report commentIf UJ was banned from these forums then people could have decent discussions without him/her stirring.All recycled Iam sorry you thought I was having a dig at you.I must learn to ignore certain individuals and not rise to the bait...pardon the pun !! :-)
Recommend?
Yes 1
No 0
-
All recycled
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 18:46
Report commentToo many crossed wires Bin Bag!! It is accurat that I have mistakenly offended, not you, me. Good grief, you are right, you try and have an informative community discussion and, as in the recycle trial, along comes the (alleged) rat in the ointment.
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 19:55
Report commentI smell a rat !!!! Now where's my warfarin ?
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 20:13
Report commentThe only menace to plague this site is Uneducated Joke aka UJ
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
ice ice baby
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 20:13
Report comment -
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 20:23
Report comment -
******
Aug 11, 20:42
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 11, 23:02
Report commentModerators I know I overstepped the mark with A***hole but enough is enough of this nasty person I know my comment will be deleted but it is time you did something about him.It is obvious others are fed-up too.Again apologies for my language.
Recommend?
Yes 5
No 0
-
ujbuckytrampfan
Unregistered User
Aug 12, 15:19
Report commentWell done Matron, your pleading did not go unnoticed. The moderators left it on long enough for everyone to have a good chortle before removing it!
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 12, 19:06
Report commentI will try harder to get you banned in future Uneducated Joke.
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
Matron
Unregistered User
Aug 16, 18:10
Report comment -
Matron
97 posts
Aug 17, 18:05
Report comment -
Matron
97 posts
Aug 18, 14:38
Report commentYou're like a festering pustule that I'd love to burst :-O
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
Matron
97 posts
Aug 19, 15:47
Report comment -
Matron
97 posts
Aug 19, 16:06
Report comment -
uncle jo
Unregistered User
Aug 19, 17:02
Report commentwhere's me medicine, I've lost, my dash pills,only got my comma, ones,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
-
******
Aug 19, 17:52
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
uncle jo
Unregistered User
Aug 19, 20:21
Report commentMe too bob the imposter, we are a sorry mess eh pal
Recommend?
Yes 0
No 0
Return to the main index, get more from this section or browse our News archives.















