Salmond denies going "mental" at MP in gay rights row
Published: 18 Aug 2011 09:30
FIRST Minister Alex Salmond has hit back at allegations that he went "absolutely mental" during a visit to Dunfermline when put on the spot by the local MP about the gay marriage controversy.
The Press broke the story on-line about the bust-up between Mr Salmond and Dunfermline Labour MP Thomas Docherty, who asked the First Minister to condemn the "despicable and disgusting comments" of SNP MSP Bill Walker about same-sex couples.
There was another twist today (Friday) when Mr Salmond's special adviser contacted the Press saying the First Minister hotly disputed the claim that he lost his temper with Mr Docherty.
In fact the claim from Rosyth SNP councillor Douglas Chapman is that Mr Salmond was "the model of restraint" in the face of "juvenile", "crass" and aggressive" behaviour from Mr Docherty.
The incident happened in a private room well away from children, teachers and the gaze of the media covering the visit to the newly opened Carnegie Primary School.
Mr Salmond's special adviser released a statement from Councillor Douglas Chapman, chair of Fife education committee, who was in the same room as Mr Salmond and Mr Docherty during their exchange.
Mr Chapman said, "Any suggestion that Mr Salmond lost his temper is absolutely incorrect.
"I was in the room along with guests and senior council officers and nothing untoward happened, other than Mr Docherty's approach was totally inappropriate given that the focus of the visit was making children feel really proud of their new school.
"In fact, most people in the room were unaware of any supposed incident and Mr Docherty and his press office are guilty of pure fiction. If anything, it was Mr Docherty's inappropriate approach to Mr Salmond that was aggressive and the First Minister's response was a model of restraint.
"Mr Docherty's childish behaviour was questionable in raising a political issue at the opening of a new school, which was a day for the proud pupils, parents and teachers.
" Mr Docherty then left - presumably to prepare his fantasy press release - and didn't even have the good grace to stay to share the day with the children.
"These actions will be seen by many of his constituents as being not only juvenile and inappropriate but wholly crass and opportunistic."
Mr Docherty said, "If Douglas Chapman's happy putting his name to this statement for Mr Salmond that's fair enough but he was in the room and he knows what really happened."
Mr Salmond's refusal to condemn his party colleague's remarks has brought fresh criticism from a students' gay rights group.
Nathan Sparling, NUS Scotland LGBT Officer and a resident of Dunfermline said, "It is inexcusable for the First Minister to have refused to condemn Bill Walker's statements.
"The SNP should distance themselves from anyone who is trying to deny the LGBT community full equality, never mind comparing them to the Nazi's.
" Bill Walker has used his own personal views in these comments and is not fully representing his constituents, and I hope not representing the views of the SNP. Alex Salmond should join those of his colleagues that have condemned these types of views in recent weeks."
Get more stories from our Roundup section
12 Mar 2014 14:30
THIS Sunday sees the Flyers not only take on Gardiner Conference rivals the Braehead Clan, but it will also be their last Late Skate event of the 2013/14 season.
12 Mar 2014 12:30 • Stuart Findlay
PUPILS at a West Fife primary school hit all the right notes as they put on a show to remember with help from Scottish Opera.
12 Mar 2014 11:30
OUR curling skills put Scotland on the map at the Winter Olympics in Russia and the sport is benefiting people in West Fife.
11 Mar 2014 15:15
WEST FIFE keglers will now be able to get into the fast lane and put a spin on their game at Dunfermline's Bowlplex.
11 Mar 2014 09:55 • Stuart Findlay
COMMUNITIES across West Fife are being given a chance to quiz council officers about their proposals to develop wind turbines.
10 Mar 2014 12:30 • Katie Richardson
One North Queensferry Primary School pupil kicked his way to the top after competing in the Scottish Taekwondo Championships.
10 Mar 2014 08:00 • Ally McRoberts
THE Soccer Sevens could end up moving to Rosyth Fleet Grounds if Pitreavie is not upgraded.
8 Mar 2014 18:05 • Gary Fitzpatrick
PARS 0 STENHOUSEMUIR 0. Dunfermline missed a string of golden chances in a goalless deadlock at East End Park.
7 Mar 2014 13:30 • Stuart Findlay
TRANSPORT Scotland have hit back at claims in a national newspaper that the new Queensferry Crossing is “unlikely to be finished on time”.
7 Mar 2014 11:30
A HEALTH conference due to be held at Dunfermline's Queen Margaret Hospital next week has been cancelled.
7 Mar 2014 10:06
LIZ SMITH, Scottish Conservative MSP for Mid Scotland & Fife, has written to the Forth Estuary Transport Authority (FETA) to call for the Union flag to fly on the Forth Road Bridge to mark the centenary anniversary of the First World War.
7 Mar 2014 10:00 • Stuart Findlay
FIFE Flyers fans are being encouraged to nominate their favourites for the team's end-of-season awards.
7 Mar 2014 09:30 • Gary Fitzpatrick
Two stars of '80s band Spear of Destiny and The Alarm are playing at PJ Molloys, Dunfermline, on Saturday night.
6 Mar 2014 13:34
HERE'S a 'Good News' story we're all particularly proud of at the Press. The Dunfermline Press has been shortlisted in the Weekly Newspaper of the Year category at the 35th annual Scottish Press Awards.
5 Mar 2014 15:30
THE four-bin roll-out expected to be completed across West Fife this autumn will help the Kingdom recycle even more waste than before.
5 Mar 2014 11:30
The long-delayed plan for the clean-up of the radiation on Dalgety Bay’s beach will be ready by the end of June.
5 Mar 2014 09:20 • Stuart Findlay
COMMUTERS endured a miserable morning after seven breakdowns around the Forth Road Bridge caused chaos on West Fife roads.
4 Mar 2014 09:00
POLICE in Fife are to launch a weekend crime crackdown targeting drug and alcohol misuse, crimes of dishonesty and anti-social behaviour.
4 Mar 2014 07:00 • Siew Peng Lee
BED-BLOCKING cost NHS Fife more than 9000 ‘bed-days’ between October and December 2013 – down 2000 from the previous quarter.