Hundreds of homes planned for ex-Hyundai site
A MAJOR part of the former Hyundai site has been earmarked for housing by new owners Shepherd Offshore with their draft masterplans revealing the possibility of more than 400 homes being built there.
The finalised proposals, to be submitted next month, will see the 150-acre site split between industrial, housing, education and retail use.
There are hopes by the developers that Carnegie College, where a relocation is currently being considered, will move into a designated 10-acre education campus.
Local MP Thomas Docherty, a supporter of the project, would also like to see a high school re-locate there eventually.
More than 220 members of the public visited a public exhibition to display potential masterplan options at the Carnegie Conference Centre on Friday and Saturday.
Up to 40 acres of land will be allocated to housing which could equate to between 400 and 500 homes.
That has raised eyebrows locally with one senior councillor telling the Press, "None of us thought we would be looking at housing on that scale. It would have a major impact on the area in terms of education provision for one thing."
Dunfermline MSP Bill Walker had spoken out against any housing on the site but backtracked after a meeting with company bosses Freddie and Bruce Shepherd, who want to create a hub for the renewables sector bringing thousands of jobs.
The developers hope to have planning permission by next March and the first permanent jobs could be created by this time next year.
In one of the four options outlined, the split is 48 acres of business and industrial use and a 40-acre residential area.
Another option sees much more emphasis on industry with 62 acres allocated compared to 25 acres for housing.
There is a three-acre retail area in all four options, located in the north west corner of the site, which has been lying vacant since it was built, dominated by the empty factory building.
That building is now in the process of being demolished, with Shepherd Offshore hoping to have cleared the site by the end of this year.
The existing three-storey office block has now been fitted out and finished. It is hoped that it will form the 'anchor' for a potential new research and development hub.
In all of the masterplan options, much of the existing landscaping on the east and west sides of the site are kept and integrated into the existing Calais Muir Woods and Duloch Park.
The exhibition was a second round of public consultation held by Shepherd Offshore in order to get feedback and suggestions from the community before submitting a planning application to Fife Council.
Members of the development team were on hand over the weekend to explain the options and answer questions. Feedback was collected on each of the four options which will be analysed to inform the final blueprint.
Andy Williamson, Shepherd Offshore's business development director, said, "It's been fantastic to have this level of interest from the community for the second event in a row.
"We are working hard to take on board all of the comments we have received over the weekend and are excited to present our final masterplan to the council as soon as possible.
"It is clear that the community and their elected representatives are keen to participate in the big debate about attracting jobs and investment to Fife."
He added, "We're here for the long-term. The (Shepherd) brothers are traditional-type businessmen who like to own things and see projects working.
"We're working very positively with the council and we've had good feedback from the local community."
Each suggestion for the entire site proposed by the public at the previous consultation meeting in June received a response regarding commercial viability.
It was 'no' to a football stadium, prison, ice rink, climbing centre, restaurant, music rehearsal space, casino/pub or a snow centre.
Possibilities include a nursery, an art college, youth drop-in centre and allotments.
A leisure centre and sport facilities got the thumbs-up as possible uses and hotels are another feasible suggestion.
It is obvious from the comments on the plans that the developers believe that the more housing space the better in terms of making the overall project work.
With 40 acres of housing: "It has maximum residential use to help cross-fund and deliver the maximum other uses." With the options which had residential down to 30 and 25 acres: "The residential component is smaller whilst the business industrial component is larger. The market conditions would not enable the quick delivery of the site and size of this component is questionable."
Carnegie College principle Geoff Fenlon, who attended the consultation event, said, "This is an exciting time for Dunfermline with several development opportunities that will support the continued regeneration of the area.
"At Carnegie College we very much see ourselves as the educational hub for the area, providing access to education and skills for all levels, from school leavers to degree courses through to those seeking to re-train as their industry develops or are seeking a new career direction.
"As such we are always looking to what is best for our learners and customers.
"We can confirm that we are at present considering several options regarding a possible relocation from our current campus.
"However, no decision about a move, if any, has been made."
Have your say. Post a comment on this article.
-
NEILY-J
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 09:07
Report commentwho suggested building a fitba stadium ther like? Pure dafty min, east end park is the theatre of dreams (no old trafford like some may say) prison is a gid shout tho, at least ma maw n that widnae hae far tae travel tae come see me ken
Recommend?
Yes 6
No 7
-
ThomasDeBois
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 09:20
Report commentThis whole redevelopment is a scam by the Shepherd brothers who have speculated on buying land for industrial use only being rezoned to residential development - making them loads of money. That is it - no jobs are being promised - just the land being redeveloped on the hope someone else will.
You cannot regenerate an area by building houses - I thought planned learnered from Easterhouse, Castlemilk etc.
Recommend?
Yes 14
No 5
-
kaka30
311 posts
Aug 26, 09:30
Report commentSounds like things are finally going to start at the ex-Hyundai site, which is great news.
I would hope though, that there is more of an emphasise on Industry & Business rather than housing.
Scotland needs jobs to be able to sustain the housing market & the Service Sector.
Whatever the experts decide though , at least things are about to get moving now.
Recommend?
Yes 6
No 4
-
dorisyeldell
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 09:42
Report commentAs the price of solar and wind technology continues to drop to more affordable levels, and as energy-efficient buildings become more popular, "green" industries will grow even more rapidly in the future hence more jobs get a degree from "High Speed University" for your career
Recommend?
Yes 7
No 1
-
molly
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 09:45
Report commentI hope there will be a few hundred new council houses among the private houses when they decide demolish the Broomhead flats.....
Recommend?
Yes 20
No 7
-
lord brown
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 10:08
Report commentgood idea molly, and with the travellers site its all go.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 10
-
******
Aug 26, 11:36
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
NoToBenefitJunkies
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 12:03
Report commentIf you have a job then you should not be taking up socially discounted houses (council houses) - only the very needy should have them. Shepherd Offshore if highly unlikely to build loss making council houses and the council will not be buying the land, so forget about it - not going to happen.
Council housing does not generate wealth, it sucks it out.
Recommend?
Yes 16
No 9
-
molly
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 12:28
Report commentLooks like the (DEXES) are at it again......
moaning !! moaning !! moaning !!
Recommend?
Yes 11
No 18
-
chieftain
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 12:59
Report commentbe ok as long as long as the priorty is developing the industrial side first before a brick is laid in the housing arena.....although i must admit my sympathy lies with neily-j and his mother.....
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 0
-
lord brown
Unregistered User
Aug 26, 14:00
Report commentall housing development must have social housing, council policy dictates that.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 8
-
TheBruce
34 posts
Aug 26, 14:23
Report commentBegs the question where the demand for this extra housing will come from, any more people move into Dunfermline = Edinburgh annex. The infrastrucure needs addressing in the town centre rather than a veiled attempt to move it further east might as well relocate the town cross outside tesco. Whats next? incorporation of M90 as part of a Dunfermline ring road?(A rhetoric remark before the Trolls start)
Recommend?
Yes 7
No 3
-
kaka30
311 posts
Aug 26, 15:32
Report commentThere wont be many new houses built anywhere untill the housing market gets back on its feet.
In order for that to happen the economy needs to grow.
For the economy to grow, the banks need to lend money to manufacturing so that they can prosper & provide employment.
Recommend?
Yes 9
No 2
-
******
Aug 26, 16:17
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
BobTheBuilder
111 posts
Aug 26, 17:59
Report commentI suppose with the Western Expansion on the cards, maybe nobody will want to live in the Eastern one anymore... Fife Council keeps telling people they've learned from past mistakes. Not convinced. Look at the issues in Kelty where one developer bought a huge swathe of land, then resold bits. Planning applications changed, totally different plans approved and voila - a balls up. Eastern expansion - innumerable house builders allowed to erect housing without a clear strategy of providing infrastructure to support it. Outcome again - a balls up. Surely by this stage anyone wanting to build houses in Dunfermline should be asked what infrastructure they are also going to contribute to before a single house is built? Incidentally, the rooms in some of the rabbit hutches are comparable in size to those built in Garvock in the 1960s and Pitcorthie in the 1970s - the DEXs of their day. Note also, many of the newest houses are all masonry and not timber frame which may affect their longer term existance.
Recommend?
Yes 9
No 3
-
SydCarrott
16 posts
Aug 27, 02:49
Report comment@ molly
I don't see anybody moaning. I see somebody trying to stir up trouble, what's your problem?
Recommend?
Yes 7
No 6
-
mikeintheknow
98 posts
Aug 28, 00:02
Report commentI have to agree with many of the above comment, I Doubt we shall see any new council housing in the area. Will a new Doctors be built either? Would it not make more since to allow Amazon to get started and see who else might wish to bring jobs to that part of the town.
Recommend?
Yes 3
No 4
-
******
Aug 28, 15:33
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
Matron
97 posts
Aug 28, 15:48
Report comment -
******
Aug 28, 16:08
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
******
Aug 28, 16:15
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
Matron
97 posts
Aug 28, 17:43
Report comment -
******
Aug 28, 17:44
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
******
Aug 28, 17:51
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
Matron
97 posts
Aug 28, 17:54
Report comment -
******
Aug 28, 17:57
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
******
Aug 28, 18:04
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
******
Aug 28, 18:27
Report commentThis comment has been removed by a moderator
-
DannyAtkins
33 posts
Aug 29, 10:12
Report commentI have to agree with TheBruce and ask where is the demand for all this extra housing is coming from? Certainly not the Dunfermline area that's for sure. A quick scan through the local estate agents windows will show many houses are struggling to sell.
It won't be long before the Eastern Expansion will be considered a 'town' in it's own right, disconnected from the rest of Dunfermline. Why would any of the people there want to come into the town centre when they have everything they need doen there? And with only a short train / car journey to Edinburgh, most won't ever see Dunfermline town centre!
Recommend?
Yes 8
No 0
-
BobTheBuilder
111 posts
Aug 29, 17:38
Report commentGood points, Danny - aside from one clump of shops, the expansion now stretches some way from these facilities. At the most extreme end out by the M90 it's maybe easier to pop in the car down to Inverkeithing rail station to get the train to Edinburgh, or indeed drive there or Livingston.
Recommend?
Yes 2
No 0
-
jollymolly
93 posts
Aug 30, 15:21
Report commentGet the area fenced off and get those houses built as quick as poss.....
before the the gypsy travellers arrive..
as nobody wants them in Cairneyhill, Cardenden and Crail .
they will be looking for vacant land.....
Recommend?
Yes 4
No 3
Return to the main index, get more from this section or browse our News archives.















