Fife Council 'committed' to improving school dinners

The most and least popular school dinners in Fife have been revealed. <i>(Image: Supplied)</i>
The most and least popular school dinners in Fife have been revealed. (Image: Supplied)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

THE most and least popular school dinners in Fife have been revealed while pupils have been told they should be eating more of what's good for them rather than what they like. 

Councillors were also informed that children had forced a switch to an "alternative cheese", as they refused to eat the product on offer, and that there are more parents telling schools what their child will and won't eat. 

Most of the requests for specialist diets relate to allergies, dairy intolerance and religious reasons, but there was "an increasing and noticeable trend" where parents ask the service to "meet the child and parents’ food preferences rather than on a medical need basis". 

A Fife Council report added: "Examples include: 'Prefers beige food', 'Food has to be cooked extra crunchy' and 'Mostly vegetarian diet, with occasional inclusion of mince'."

Here's a look at a primary school menu in Fife. What takes your fancy? Here's a look at a primary school menu in Fife. What takes your fancy? (Image: Fife Council) READ MORE: A 'football league table' of school dinners and where to hide the veg ...

School dinners was a hot topic at the education and scrutiny committee last week and the top five sellers, in Fife primary schools between August 2024 and January 2025, were named as beefburgers, bubble coated fish, Margherita pizza, wrap with sliced cheese and chicken korma.

The least popular, going by sales in the same timeframe, were crushed coronation chickpea wrap, crushed coronation chickpea roll, roasted cauliflower dinner, creamy korma with broccoli and cauliflower and chicken tikka mayonnaise roll.

The committee was told these choices were "very unpopular" with the pupils and there had "not been a great take up for the vegetable dishes". 

Tariq Ditta, head of the facilities management service which is responsible for providing school meals, said a desire to improve the fare on offer had led to primary school consultations, including face-to-face sit downs with pupils, getting underway last year. 

As a result of the feedback, the beefburger was upgraded to a cheeseburger, the fish dish was changed to one with a different coating, pepperoni was added to the pizza and the korma was changed to a chicken Makhani style dish. 

One councillor said she'd been told kids were "taking the cheese out of wraps and sandwiches as they don't like the cheese" and just eating plain wraps and bread. 

Shirley McKie, the hospitality manager for the service, said this had been raised in the consultations and the suppliers had since introduced an "alternative cheese" that had proved popular.

And this is the fare that's typically on offer in Fife's high schools. And this is the fare that's typically on offer in Fife's high schools. (Image: Fife Council) Cllr Auxi Barrera said: "There's a breakdown in the report of food and meals that children don't like. 

"I'm fussy but I wouldn't like to try them either. 

"If we already have this information, why do we continue to serve these foods in our schools and nurseries?

"This will lead to food waste, a waste of money and children going hungry. 

"I'm aware of some children just having a snack as there's nothing on the menu they would like to have."

Mr Ditta said the "preferences of children is a very difficult one" and the guidelines, set out by the Scottish Government, are more along the lines of what pupils should eat, because it's good for them, rather than what they like, which may not be good for them. 

School dinners was a hot topic at last week's meeting. School dinners was a hot topic at last week's meeting. (Image: Newsquest) READ MORE: The signs are good for the opening of a new Dunfermline restaurant

He added: "We need to understand this whole issue of school meals, and free school meals, is actually to improve the health of our pupils. 

"I take the point about there may be some items that are popular and some less so but in the report we've showed we are listening to stakeholders, including the children, about the products they do and don't like and that will go back into the menu development cycle."

At the committee meeting Mr Ditta fielded complaints and concerns about the quality, price, choice, portion sizes and taste of school dinners, and said the service has to balance what's on offer with government regulations on what they can serve and the budget they have.

He said another issue was the "large increase" in requests for specialist diets and exclusion of food ingredients: "A few years ago it was 300 and now it's about 900, which we are getting through but it's been a real pressure point."

Examples include: Halal (authorised and not solely relating to meat products); Dairy - eggs, soy, nuts, tomato; Unique allergies - such as Xanthan gum, potassium sorbate, citric acid; 'Beige diets', which are demanded more in additional support units. 

Mr Ditta's report explained: "Some parents, on behalf of their child, are specifically asking for chips, chicken nuggets and white bread." 

In response to questions about what's in school dinners, he said details such as the calories, ingredients, nutritional value, fat, sugar and salt was all available on the website.

His report said conditions such as diabetes, obesity and high blood pressure stem from poor diet and insufficient exercise but recognised that changing a nation's food habits is a big ask.

Mr Ditta continued: "The whole agenda of eating more healthily is not just a Scottish problem, it's a UK problem and a western nations problem. 

"We've really got to move away from calorie-dense products to more nutrient-dense products. 

"That's a huge agenda and it's not going to be changed very easily."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos