One of the darkest periods in West Fife’s history is marked out on the shoreline in Torryburn by an ordinary looking slab of stone.
This unremarkable site is the grave of Lilias Adie, a woman who was accused of witchcraft in the 18th century and who died before she could be brought to trial.
While in her 60s, she was accused by a neighbour, Jean Nelson, of causing her ill-health.
Unfortunately for Lilias, the Reverend Allan Logan also lived in Torryburn, and she would have been taken to him in order to answer for her “crimes”.
A reconstruction of Lilias; face, showing what she would have looked like.(Image: University of Dundee)
He was known to be a witch finder and pricker (someone who used needles or pins to prick the skin of suspected witches to look for the devil’s mark).
READ MORE: New play to focus on women killed as Torryburn witches
Lilias died in prison in 1704, possibly by suicide. Had she lived to be found guilty of witchcraft, she would have been facing execution.
Her body was buried on the shoreline in Torryburn and placed under the stone. The thinking was this would prevent her corpse from coming back and haunting those who had persecuted her.
Her grave is the only known one of a witch in Scotland, as most were strangled at the stake and then their bodies burnt.
The Reverend Logan continued to serve as minister of Torryburn until 1717, when he moved to Culross. He remained there until his death in 1733.
According to the Fasti Ecclesiae Scoticanae, which provides details on Scottish ministers, he also left a sum of money to the poor of Culross and Torryburn.
Nowadays, Lilias’ grave is not the village’s only reminder of its grisly past. A street was named after her, Adia Road, but another street was also named after the Reverend, Logan Road.
READ MORE: Women of West Fife: Bessie Bittern and Lilias Adie
Lilias' grave as seen from the shoreline.(Image: Alexandra Baff)
The name for Logan Road was chosen by a local area committee around the year 2000.
But should a man who was so heavily invested in Scotland’s witch trials have received such a high honour?
Jemma Black, from Newmills, spoke to the Press on how she felt when she discovered the history behind Logan Road’s name.
“I first found out about the street being named after the Reverend Logan at the Torryburn and Newmills History Society. They did a talk on the Torryburn Witches approximately 18 years ago.
Logan Road in Torryburn.(Image: Alexandra Baff)
“It was a very interesting talk as I'd only ever heard local tales about the witches, this was more factual, which portrayed the victims as women rather than witches, and took away the myth.
“The women were humanised in this talk, and it suddenly felt far more uncomfortable hearing their names. It became far more personal.
“I had known previously that on the new (at the time) estate, one street was named after a lady murdered for being accused of being a witch, and that another street was named after the man who condemned her to death, but it was only after hearing the stories in detail that it seemed so wrong that his name was chosen.
“I think I just accepted it as part of Torryburn local history, but it always felt uncomfortable to me.”
READ MORE: Voices and Visions of the Witch exhibit opens in Dunfermline
She added: “We can't and shouldn't eradicate history. This man, in the name of religion, condemned innocent women to be brutally tortured and ultimately murdered. This was misogyny, tyranny, and sociopathy at it's very worst.
“He should definitely be remembered as someone far more evil and deranged than any of his victims could ever be. Just as we learn about other people in power who have harmed, it is important that we know this man existed.
“As a side note, it's interesting that some years after Logan had left Torryburn, he asked for the files and records of his time here.
“Thankfully his request was turned down, otherwise I'm pretty sure his name would have just died out with people's memories.”
There are several groups working to remember Scotland’s witches, including, The Creative Coven, which was created by Rowan Morrison to bring together creatives whose work is inspired by the witch hunts.
The Bronze plaque which marks Lilias' grave.(Image: Alexandra Baff)
Speaking on Logan Road, Rowan commented: “I definitely think it should be changed, I think it’s time that these grave injustices were brought to the forefront.
“I think it would be the least that could happen to change its name and rename it after the women that he persecuted.
“That would be a step towards the healing of all these horrific events.
“We can’t change history, it’s not about that.
“We can make changes to things that happened in the past, like the First Minister’s apology for historic witch persecution.
“So, I think that is looking at place names, because Scotland is somewhere that place names are really important.”
READ MORE: Memorial for Scottish witches held at Dunfermline Abbey
Brandon Ferguson, of production company HeadlessActing, wrote the play ‘The Seven Witches of Torryburn’ to show that the women caught up in the hysteria of the witch trials were ordinary, innocent women.
The play will come to Torryburn next year, before touring various locations across Scotland.
The play, 'The Seven Witches of Torryburn' will tour next year.(Image: Contributed)
Brandon said: “Logan Road needs to be renamed.
“Reverend Allan Logan is not someone who should be honoured with a street name.
“While it’s important to acknowledge that much of the blame for his actions lies with the wider church and the culture of that time, Reverend Logan’s legacy remains one of fear, superstition, and systemic oppression.
“His role in the persecution of innocent people left behind a legacy of pain and suffering.
“Today, we are rightly re-evaluating the history of the witch trials and choosing to remember and honour the victims of those dark times. Naming a street after someone involved in that injustice sends the wrong message.
READ MORE: Fife witches to be remembered during day of Remembrance
“The way forward is clear: Logan Road should be renamed. I would love to see it dedicated to one of the seven women who were murdered in 1666 – women whose stories were never heard.”
The Press put the question to our readers on social media.
When asked on Instagram if they thought it was right to name a street after the Reverend, 55 per cent said no, 32 per cent said yes, and 13 per cent were unsure.
Mary Keggan commented: “It’s a sad tale but back then they thought they were doing good! You can’t change the past unfortunately, but thank goodness we learned from it.”
Paul Cochrane posted: "'You can't change history', sure, but you can stop honouring a man who was responsible for murdering women. Take away the witchcraft angle, and that guy was a serial killer.”
It raises the question, how do we remember victims of the witch trials in a way that honours their memories?
On a recent trip to Torryburn while researching Lilias, I went down to her grave.
While I was there, other visitors asked me if the stone was the “witch’s grave”. One of the group proceeded to walk out towards it, stand on top of Lilias’ grave, and pose for a photograph.
Now that Lilias is being rightfully remembered by history, her grave has become an attraction, and that brings with it a whole different set of problems about how we should pay our respects to her.
Torryburn is steeped in the history of witch trials, and it’s up to West Fife to keep Lilias’ name alive, and how we do that appropriately is an ongoing discussion.
However, my recent trip to Torryburn has taught me one thing.
A woman who died in the most tragic way, has been reduced to a photo opportunity.
Share