Find, save and share Public Notices that affect you in the area.
Search the Public Notice Portal What is the Public Notice Portal?What is the Public Notice Portal?
The Public Notice Portal carries statutory public notices published in local newspapers and is the fastest and most effective way of finding out what is happening in YOUR neighbourhood.
Search the Public Notice PortalPROPOSALS for 180 houses on an ancient battlefield at Rosyth can go ahead despite concerns that developers may "dig up bodies" from four centuries ago.
Alfred Stewart Property Foundation (ASPF) Ltd, set up in memory of the late West Fife businessman, have been granted planning permission in principle to build on 26 acres of sloping farmland at Castlandhill.
However, the west and central planning committee heard that the revised residential development - originally there was talk of 550 homes - could uncover the remains of Scottish and English soldiers who fought and died there.
Drone footage of the site at Castlandhill. Plans for 180 houses have been approved. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
Councilor David Alexander highlighted one of the conditions which says the developer must provide for the investigation, identification and recording of any "archaeological remains" on the site.
He asked: "What are we talking about here? Are we talking about bodies?"
Alastair Hamilton, the council's service manager in development management, said: "It could, potentially, but the issue is that's not something that's necessarily recorded specifically.
"But equally, that can happen anywhere.
Drone footage of the site at Castlandhill. Plans for 180 houses have been approved. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
"I think from memory there was a thumb found on a site in St Andrews."
Last month was the 375th anniversary of the second Battle of Inverkeithing, also known as the Battle of Pitreavie, which took place on July 20, 1651.
Oliver Cromwell’s English forces defeated a smaller Scottish army in a short but brutal clash, with an estimated 1,600 Scots killed and 1,200 taken prisoner.
Cllr Alexander asked: "If we do find remains, or even substantial numbers, what do we do?"
Mr Hamilton replied: "There are processes involved where the police have to ensure that they are archaeological artefacts but then they are dealt with in a certain way.
This is the planned housing site at Castlandhill in Rosyth. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
"It is a battlefield so there may be, but there have been developments on battlefields and there are processes in place to deal with what's discovered.
"It's an extensive area, all the way from Inverkeithing to the bottom of Dunfermline.
"It was quite a widespread battle in that sense so there are bits all over the place."
He added: "If they find anything specific, particularly human remains, it's all done in a prescribed and respectful way."
Beyond the historical concerns, more contemporary issues were also raised.
A view of the Castlandhill site from the Granville Way area of Rosyth. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
Cllr Sam Steele was worried that development could worsen existing flooding problems in the area.
She said: "One resident has been put out of her home four times in Hudson Road because of horrendous flooding."
Mr Hamilton said the new development should help reduce the risk of "flash flooding".
He explained: "If there's a high level of rainfall, at present that will just flow off the site, whereas with the SUDS (sustainable urban drainage) system it will collect and slowly release it and moderate that impact.
"That's what this is designed to do."
Drone footage of the site at Castlandhill. Plans for 180 houses have been approved. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
The committee was told the Castlandhill site contains a scattering of farm buildings and residential properties, historic telecommunications masts, buildings associated "with the Rosyth wireless telegraph station and covered reservoirs that supplied water to the garden city and the admiralty docks".
A quarter of the 180 homes will be affordable housing and the plans also include new access roads, landscaping and open space.
There were 35 objections with concerns about traffic, loss of green space, wildlife, the impact on schools and local health services, parking, road safety and visual impact.
The proposal is smaller than earlier versions.
ASPF presented multi-million-pound plans in 2022 for a Northern Gateway scheme with 200 homes, a hotel and a Queensferry Country Park covering more than 100 acres.
That did not proceed.
Drone footage of the site at Castlandhill. Plans for 180 houses have been approved. (Image: Fife Council planning papers.)
Public consultation took place in April 2024 on 550 homes. When an application was submitted by November that year, the number had fallen to 360.
Following discussions with the council, it was halved and 180 homes have now been approved subject to 27 conditions and a legal agreement.
ASPF must pay £327,780 towards strategic transport intervention measures and £819,045 for education capacity in the Dunfermline area. Both payments will be index linked.
Share