Babcock chief says communication on nuclear subs should be better

The Submarine Dismantling Project is underway at Rosyth Dockyard. <i>(Image: Newsquest)</i>
The Submarine Dismantling Project is underway at Rosyth Dockyard. (Image: Newsquest)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A Babcock chief has said the company cannot say how long radioactive material will be kept in Rosyth.

The Submarine Dismantling Project (SDP) is designed to safely defuel, strip and recycle 27 decommissioned Royal Navy nuclear watercrafts, seven of which are being dealt with at the defence contractor’s West Fife dockyard.

HMS Swiftsure is serving as the 'demonstrator' boat to establish a repeatable, standardised process for the rest of the fleet, and the process is expected to be completed by the end of the year.

Local SNP councillor, Brian Goodall, had questioned how long the radioactive reactor pressure vessel being cut out of it will have to be stored for, but reportedly not received an answer.

Chief growth officer for Babcock, Sir Nick Hine, was asked for an update by the Press.

He said: “It’s not mine to answer, because that’s a customer conversation. I’d store it as long as I have to and not any longer than I need to.

“The customer decides how long we have to store it for, and then what they’re going to do with it after the event.”

The Ministry of Defence has been approached for comment.

Sir Hine admitted after recent criticism that dialogue between the firm and those who live near to its facility could be better.

“We should do better at communicating how safe all of this stuff is, and actually the levels of risk are really low,” he said.

“You get more natural radiation from granite in Scotland than you do from a nuclear submarine.

“I’ve been in the nuclear space all my life, and you can tell by looking at me that there’s nothing wrong with me.”

The UK Government classes the reactor pressure vessels as “intermediate level radioactive waste”, and it is the component in its subs that remains radioactive for the longest period.  

Meanwhile, the United States Environmental Protection Agency says that the amount of radioactivity in building materials such as granite are “typically very, very low”.

A spokesperson for the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament recently said: “It is only rational for Rosyth locals and community leaders to be concerned about possible environmental and health hazards posed by legacy nuclear devices like submarine reactors.

“It is well understood that such devices stay hazardous for long durations, and that any additional exposure to radioactivity can be dangerous to humans, especially pregnant women and girls.”

The SDP is the first scheme of its kind, and Babcock has hopes of expanding the programme at its facility.”

Sir Hine said: “It’s the only time it’s ever been done in the world, and we’re doing it in an environmentally safe way. It’s a real positive and we should be making more of that, and we should be doing it with the community.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos