Former Dunfermline soldier wins £300,000 MoD settlement

James McGarry, who joined the Army as a teenager after leaving school in 2000 <i>(Image: Supplied)</i>
James McGarry, who joined the Army as a teenager after leaving school in 2000 (Image: Supplied)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

A former soldier from Dunfermline has secured a £300,000 gross settlement after a cold-weather injury suffered during Army training brought his military career to an early end.

James McGarry, now 42, was one of two former British Army personnel to receive compensation totalling £700,000 gross, following claims against the Ministry of Defence.

Mr McGarry joined the Army as a teenager after leaving school in 2000, hoping to build a long-term career in the military.

However, during basic training in January 2001, he developed a non-freezing cold injury (NFCI) after taking part in a four-to-five-day outdoor exercise in cold, wet and windy conditions.

He slept outside under a poncho, with his feet remaining cold and wet throughout the exercise.

They became numb, swollen and painful, and by the final day were discoloured, making it difficult for him to walk or put weight on them.

After reporting his symptoms, he remained in the field until the exercise ended before spending three days in hospital, where he was diagnosed with NFCI.

Although he continued training and later joined his regiment, further exposure to cold worsened his symptoms, including burning, numbness and pins and needles in his toes.

He was eventually medically discharged in 2005, aged just 21.

Mr McGarry said: "Having my Army career cut short by injury was incredibly difficult, so reaching this outcome has been very important to me.

"Gwen and the team have been wonderful throughout and have always been professional and supportive.

"They kept in touch, answered my questions and guided me through every step of the claim, helping me feel supported during a challenging time.

"I’m very grateful for everything they have done and couldn’t be happier with the outcome."

To this day Mr McGarry continues to experience pain, numbness, and pins and needles in cold weather, and now works indoors to avoid exposure to the cold.

His case is one of two recently settled by Hugh James, a law firm specialising in military claims, with both involving NFCI sustained during winter training.

The total value of the settlements reached £700,000, with Mr McGarry receiving £300,000 gross and the second, unnamed soldier, receiving £400,000.

Nia-Wyn Evans, partner in the Hugh James Military team, said the cases highlighted the serious impact NFCI can have on service personnel.

Ms Evans said: "Both of these cases show the profound and lasting impact that a non-freezing cold injury can have on a serviceperson’s life and career.

"Both of our clients joined the Army with every intention of building a long-term future in the military, but their injuries changed that path entirely.

"We are pleased to have supported these clients in pursuing a claim that reflects not only the physical symptoms they continue to live with, but also the loss of the military career they had worked so hard to achieve."

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos