Women of West Fife: Bessie Bittern and Lilias Adie

Numerous West Fife women were accused of witchcraft. <i>(Image: Fife Council/ University of Dundee/ Carolyn Sutton)</i>
Numerous West Fife women were accused of witchcraft. (Image: Fife Council/ University of Dundee/ Carolyn Sutton)
This article is brought to you by our exclusive subscriber partnership with our sister title USA Today, and has been written by our American colleagues. It does not necessarily reflect the view of The Herald.

March is Women’s History Month and it is a time to reflect on the contributions of women to society, culture, and our heritage.

The Press is looking back at some of the important women who have come from, or lived in, West Fife and Dunfermline.

We’re now looking at the lives of two West Fife women who were accused of witchcraft, Bessie Bittern and Lilias Adie, and the legacy they left behind.

The witch trials truly kicked off in Scotland in all its horror under the reign of King James VI, who would later go on to also become James I of England.

A marriage between James and Anne of Denmark was agreed, and the bride set sail for her new country.

However, the journey was perilous, and her ship was forced to turn back. James went to Denmark himself to see his new wife, but again on the journey back, there were violent storms that threatened their safety.

An investigation was launched into the journeys, with claims being made that witches had interfered with the voyages.

READ MORE: Memorial for Scottish witches held at Dunfermline Abbey

This seems to have began an obsession in King James with witches and the supernatural, and the king going on to write a book dedicated to the matter called Daemonologie in 1597.

This is the context in which many Scottish women, and some men, lost their lives.

One Dunfermline woman who was accused of witchcraft and lived to tell the tale was Auld Bessie Bittern, or Boswell.

Gregor Stewart writes in his book, Secret Dunfermline: “Said to be a woman not to cross or disagree with, and muttering what was taken to be curses to anyone who caused her any frustration, it was inevitable that locals would begin to suspect her as being a witch, and the addition of her large black cat did nothing to quell people’s fears.”

The story goes that Bessie asked a weaver named Johnnie if he could dig some potatoes for her.

A ceremony to remember those accused of witchcraft was held in Dunfermline last year.A ceremony to remember those accused of witchcraft was held in Dunfermline last year. (Image: David Wardle) Johnnie’s wife objected to this request and said that he would not have time to do so, as he needed to make cloth for an order.

Gregor Stewart added: “Bessie expressed her annoyance at her refusal to allow her husband to help her, a poor old lady, and assured her she would not be any richer from her refusal before leaving the shop with her cat.”

The next day Johnnie got back to working on the piece of cloth but every time he tried to pick up his shuttle, it would fly out of his hand.

READ MORE: Women of West Fife: Saint Margaret and Queen Matilda

The weaver now believed himself to be bewitched by Bessie and even threw the shuttle into his fire three times.

Bessie was arrested for witchcraft. However, she was not executed as many others were and instead was banished from Dunfermline.

Gregor Stewart adds: “She was fortunate in that the full effect of the Witchcraft Act of that year was not implemented.”

This refers to the Witchcraft Act on 1563 was introduced during the reign of Mary, Queen of Scots.

As previously reported in the Press, this act was on Scottish statute books for the best part of 200 years until it was repealed as a result of a House of Lords amendment for the post-union Witchcraft Act 1735.

One West Fife woman who was not as lucky, was Lilias Adie. She lived in Torryburn, which was also the home of Reverend Allan Logan.

Lilias Adie as she may have appeared in the early 1700s.Lilias Adie as she may have appeared in the early 1700s. (Image: University of Dundee/BBC Radio Scotland/PA) He was known to be a very successful witch finder and pricker (someone who used needles or pins to prick the skin of suspected witches to look for the devil’s mark).

Gregor Stewart states in Secret Dunfermline: “His reputation was such that during his weekly sermons, he would regularly suddenly stop and stare angrily towards the congregation before pointing his finger towards someone and shouting, ‘You, Witch! Rise and be gone from the Tables of the Lord.’

“On almost every occasion, one terrified elderly woman would think he was pointing at her and stand to leave the church, only to be arrested outside by the local baillie and taken by armed guard to the jail to await trial.”

It is easy in this situation to imagine the fear that Lilias, an elderly woman, felt when she was accused by her neighbour, Jean Nelson (also referred to as Jean Bizet) of causing her ill-health.

Lilias confessed to the crime, but most likely only did so because she was confused and terrified.

READ MORE: Historical women of West Fife: Amelia Robertson Hill

Those accused of witchcraft were often subjected to torture by not being allowed to sleep, guards would even walk them around their cells by pulling a rope that was put around their heads.

Devices such as witch forks, a metal collar with spikes, were also used to prevent them from dozing off.

The University of Edinburgh’s Introduction to Scottish Witchcraft states: “Confession evidence was often gathered under torture, with the most common kind of torture being sleep deprivation.”

Lilias Adie's marker stone on Torryburn beach.Lilias Adie's marker stone on Torryburn beach. (Image: Fife Council) Lilias came up with a story that she had encountered a man, who was really the Devil, in a cornfield. She admitted to having sex with him and lured other women to him.

Official records from the time state that she was burned at the stake on Torryburn Beach, however she actually died in jail before her trial, possibly by suicide.

Her body was buried on the shoreline in Torryburn under a stone slab. This was to prevent her corpse from being reanimated and haunting those who had persecuted her in life.

People also believed at the time that witches could not cross moving water, and so the tide would stop her from leaving her grave.

However, Lilias was still unable to find peace. Her resting place was disturbed, and her skull removed on the orders of Dunfermline damask designer, Joseph Neil Paton.

It is thought that it eventually came into the care of the University of St Andrews, but her skull has since gone missing. The stone slab she was buried under can still be seen today.

Photos of her skull taken 100 years ago at the University of St Andrews allowed a facial reconstruction to be created in 2017 by Dr Christopher Rynn. It is consequently the only known face of a Scottish woman accused of witchcraft.

Despite dying back in 1704, she is still remembered in Dunfermline to this day.

An exhibition called Witches in Word, Not Deed was held at Dunfermline Carnegie Library and Galleries (DCLG) last year.

It consisted of 13 dresses that were all personalised and imprinted with words used against each of the women accused of witchcraft.

Its creator, Carolyn Sutton, has created a new work that commemorates Lilias Adie specifically.

The artwork, which is a bonnet, or coif, is imprinted with text from a medical presentation discussing the phrenological studies done in 1884 to her skull.

The bonnet made by Carolyn Sutton for DCLG. The bonnet made by Carolyn Sutton for DCLG. (Image: Carolyn Sutton) READ MORE: Fife witches to be remembered during day of remembrance

Carolyn told the Press: “I had been in talks with DCLG for a while about making some new pieces for local women that would become part of their permanent collection.

“We were hoping to do two pieces, actually, and we really wanted them to be presented alongside the full Witches in Word, Not Deed exhibition, but there wasn’t any funding available at that time.

“Lilias was always part of the plan, but we had originally hoped to also do another dress for an accused woman from Dunfermline.

“We were lucky enough for some funding to become available through DCLG to do some of the work after the exhibition run was over, and they really liked the idea I had for remembering Lilias, so they asked that I go ahead with that piece.

The work commemorating Lilias is on display at DCLG.The work commemorating Lilias is on display at DCLG. (Image: Carolyn Sutton) “Lilias’ story is relatively well known, especially by people from that area in Fife, and it made sense to remember her and talk about what happened to her because it was so unusual.

“The types of accusations she faced and the fact that she died in prison are sadly rather commonly seen throughout the witchcraft trials, but it was what happened to her after that made Lilias’ story so unique.”

Carolyn highlighted that Lilias not only suffered in life, but that ignorance and fascination continued her suffering even into death.

“Because Lilias’ skull was studied by phrenologists and they said such terrible things about her, and then her skull went missing after being shown at the Empire Exhibition in Glasgow and still hasn’t been found, I thought I would make a bonnet for her.

“The whole project has been about the loss of these women, and in Lilias’ case, her missing skull really makes a point about the exploitation these people suffered; not just in life, but also in death, and even long after,” She commented.

The bonnet is now on display at the Reading Rooms in DCLG alongside an interpretation panel that has information about Lilias’ life and what happened to her after her death.

It is in the same cabinet as a walking stick that was made from the wood of Lilias’ coffin.

Many more people were accused of witchcraft in West Fife. An interactive map launched by the University of Edinburgh lists the names of all those persecuted in Scotland.

READ MORE: Culross and its history: From saints to accused witches

In Culross alone there are numerous names, some of those included are Catherine Rowane, Katherine Mitchell, Marion Thomson, Margaret Holden and Helen Eliot.

A small selection of the names found in Aberdour include the wife of Henry Stanehouse, Susanna Alexander, Elspeth Kirkland, and the wife of Thomas Smith. Clearly, the names of some of these women have been lost to history.

Carolyn commented on why she feels it is important to still remember those who lost their lives as a result of the witch trials.

“I think it’s important to highlight as many personal stories of the people accused as possible, really, as they help us understand that these were just people who found themselves in horrible and undeserved situations.

“These things could have happened to any of us, and in some parts of the world, these things are still happening. By learning more about this difficult history and others like it, we have to hope we can learn from past mistakes and do better.

“By making work remembering local people who fell victim to the witch trials, and being able to have these pieces kept in their own communities, there is a special connection that’s made possible between the past and present in these places.

“These people could have been us, or our family members, or our neighbours, and acknowledging that and seeing ourselves in these stories creates an opportunity to relate to them in a way we might not get otherwise.”

Get involved
with the news

Send your news & photos