FOR the third successive game Dunfermline and Carnegie were involved in a knife-edge finish, but unlike the two previous East of Scotland First Division fixtures, they lost at Tranent and Preston Village on Saturday, suffering their first league defeat of the season.
But with second top side, Watsonians 2nd XI, also losing, the McKane Park side stay top of the table.
Batting on a difficult Polwarth Park wicket was awkward for both sides, and some indifferent shots by the Dunfermline and Carnegie batters saw a massive late collapse set-in and them go from 123 for 3 to 125 all out!
Zane Schlebusch and Anthony Xavier had put together a partnership of 94, after three wickets had fallen for just 29 runs, and it seemed they were heading for a good score.
But once the pair were separated only two runs were added, and even allowing for the batting conditions, it was a very reachable score.
Certainly Tranent's batters found the early going tough against an eager DCCC attack, and wickets fell regularly.
But a stubborn knock by home vice-captain, Ragesh Kulimmarathinangal, kept them very much in the picture, although when he was seventh out for 43, with still 18 runs needed, visiting hopes were still high.
However, a battling innings by Loke Natarajan, partnered by stubborn number 10, Dougie Russell, saw them over the line with two wickets in hand.
Dunfermline and Carnegie skipper, Vasu Reddy, was very unhappy to lose the match: “Yes, it was a poor track, but to lose seven wickets for two runs is simply not good enough and we simply didn't deserve to win.
“There will have to be a massive improvement when RH Corstorphine come to McKane this Saturday.”
Dunfermline and Carnegie (7) 125, Z Schlebusch 77, A Xavier 24, A Kumar 4 for 16, D De Silva 3 for 17.
Tranent and Preston Village (20) 126 for 8, R Kulimmarathinangal 43, A Kumar 28, L Natarajan 14 not out, S Nathan 2 for 10, M Irfan 2 for 15.
DUNFERMLINE and Carnegie 2nd XI stayed in second top spot in Division 4 by comfortably beating Tranent and Preston Village 3rd XI at McKane Park.
Tranent were under pressure from the start of their innings, with the home attack bowling very economically and runs being hard to come by for the visitors.
They were dismissed for 133, and in reply aggressive batting by Waseem Khan, who completed a half century in 42 balls, and Arav Dejesh, saw victory achieved in 24 overs.
Tranent and Preston Village (5) 133, C Beduduri 23, A Hassan 3 for 12, S Ali 2 for 22.
Dunfermline and Carnegie 2nd XI (20) 134 for 2, W Khan 53, A Dejesh 41 not out, G Grover 27 not out.
A POWERFUL batting performance against Stewart's/Melville 4th XI, at Inverleith on Saturday, opened the door for Dunfermline and Carnegie 3rd XI to maintain their place at the top of Division 7.
Although they lost some early wickets, excellent contributions from Douglas Shanks and Mannoteja Mode saw the DCCC side post an impressive tally in excess of 200.
A superb eight overs from Albin James saw Stew/Mel wickets fall, and while they batted their 40 overs, they were never really in the hunt.
Dunfermline and Carnegie 3rd XI (20) 217 for 9, M Mode 81, D Shanks 35, C Bond 27 not out, M Coyle 5 for 37.
Stewart's/ Melville 4th XI (10) 154 for 8, M Allan 73 not our, A James 3 for 10.
DUNFERMLINE and Carnegie 4th XI lost ground in their bid to stay in the Division 9 promotion race, losing at Winchburgh.
DCCC made a poor start on being asked to bat and were 28 for 6 at one stage, but good contributions from Christiaan and Jaques Maritz saw the side bat their allotment of 40 overs putting together a decent total.
Winchburgh lost early wickets, but then stabilised through good contributions from Indhu Shekhar and Musadiq Syed and this saw them comfortably home.
Dunfermline and Carnegie 4th XI (6) 122, C Maritz 32, J Moritz 18, R Singh 5 for 22, M Syed 2 for 17.
Winchburgh (20) 123 for 4, M Syed 40, I Shekhar 39 not out.
ON Sunday Dunfermline and Carnegie got back on the winning track when they went to Hughenden to face Hillhead in the Scottish Challenge Cup second round.
DCCC were asked to bat and put together a massive total of 246 in 40 overs, with Anthony Xavier making an unbeaten 85 and Zane Schlebusch scoring 37.
Hillhead, from the West District League structure, struggled from the first ball and finished 193 runs short.
Dunfermline and Carnegie 246 for 8, A Xavier 85 not out, Z Schlebusch 37, M Shafiq 26, R Braizer 3 for 61, S Rekken 2 for 48.
Hillhead 53, Z Schlebusch 4 for 11, B Amjad 3 for 9.
THE Dunfermline and Carnegie Development team were outgunned by Livingston 4th XI in a high scoring ESCA Sunday League game at The Cairns.
Livingston 4th XI (20) 199, A Sharma 40, I Ahmad 33, M Spiers 2 for 23.
Dunfermline and Carnegie Development 176 for 6, D Shanks 69 not out, C Leitch 40, M Ahmad 2 for 26, S Dubey 2 for 26.
BROOMHALL went down by five wickets to Kinloch 2nd XI in a Perthshire and Strathmore Cricket Union Division 2 game at The Cairns, on Saturday.
A fine innings by home skipper Scott Lucas, who hit 93, saw Broomhall post a very useful total of 179, but Kinloch's batters looked confident and reached their target in 32 overs.
Broomhall (8) 179, S Lucas 93, E Breen 25, H Raees 3 for 14, M Asif 2 for 40.
Kinloch 2nd XI (20) 184 for 5, H Raees 53 not out, M Habib 45, G Kahlon 2 for 23.
Share